|
Crossover Towing
By Keith Burton
In a day when everyone is concerned about the rising
costs of fuel, nearly every manufacturer of cars and trucks is offering
what has become known as Crossover Utility Vehicles, or CUVs. These CUVs
are lightduty vehicles, many with the same passenger space as Sport
Utility Vehicles, which have become the poster child of fuel hogs in the
news media.
As a result, many people are buying these lighter
CUVs, even folks that have boats to tow, as replacements for their thirsty
SUVs. But is this a good decision? It can be if you do your research and
if you keep in mind what you are towing.
CUVs are not trucks. They may look like a regular SUV
in many ways, some are almost as large. But almost all crossover vehicles
are based upon automobile platforms. |
|

Fuel Sipping 2008 Toyota Yaris Sedan
by Keith Burton
With gas prices breaking records many commuters are looking
for cars that are better than the average on their thirst for
fuel. Toyota's Yaris is among those cars. Yes, it is a small
car, but it is not like the small cars of the past.
Not to many years ago auto manufacturers relegated small cars
to the back of
their inventory as SUVs, pickups and luxury cars got all the
engineering. But not
so today. The latest crop of small, fuel-efficient cars are
packed with the state-of ---the-art in engine technology and are
comfortably equipped. They even have interesting styling and are
surprisingly roomy inside for their compact size.
Click Here for the Full
Story |
|
They have unibody frames where the body of the
vehicle is designed to carry and distribute loads, and they do not a
frame as in a regular truck or SUV. These unibody designs are quite
strong and they save weight, which helps these vehicles get better
mileage.
Many CUVs also offer engines and transmissions
that have plenty of power to tow, but again, it depends on the
vehicle. What it boils down to is that not all CUVs make good tow
vehicles. This means you will have to do more research to find one
that will do the job you want.
The unibody design means that there is not a
frame for a hitch to be attached. Instead, the unibody is engineered
with specially strengthened mounting points to connect the hitch.
Most CUVs can have a hitch attached but that doesn’t automatically
mean that the vehicle can handle the same loads as a regular
truck-based SUV. Using a CUV to tow a load in excess of the rated
limits can cause serious damage to the hitch points of the CUV, and
extremely expensive repairs.
LOTS OF CHOICES
CUVs come is almost a bewildering number of
body styles, engine size and performance. There are over 60
different models from manufacturers. They range from light duty
vehicles such as the Toyota Rav 4 and Honda CR-V, to sport-oriented
CUVs like the Honda MDX and BWM X5, to some new larger CUVs like the
Saturn Outlook and GMC Acadia.
CUVs have a lot going for them and that is why
manufacturers are offering so many different versions. They
typically get better mileage than truck-based SUVs, they drive and
handle more car-like in everyday situations, and they have the
interior space, and upright seating that many drivers prefer and
enjoy in SUVs.
Many of the CUVs are also front wheel drivers
that is unlike a typical truck-based SUV where the rear wheels drive
the vehicle forward. Rear wheel drive is what most people are
accustomed to for tow vehicles and rear drive has some advantages
for towing, especially at boat ramps where the greater weight on the
rear wheels helps with traction. Front wheel drive vehicles often
have some trouble pulling boats up a ramp as the weight at the rear
of the vehicle reduces traction at the front.
Even CUVs with all-wheel-drive have the
drivetrain bias for front-wheel-drive in normal driving, only
sending power to the rear wheels when slip is detected. There are
some CUVs that are available with transmissions that engage the
all-wheel-drive system on demand, such as the Honda Pilot.
What you should know is that before you choose
a CUV and you have a boat to tow, you need to first be sure that you
know the total weight of the boat, trailer and gear that you will be
hauling. This figure will help you find a CUV that has the capacity,
the horsepower and towing performance to the job.
GETTING INFORMATION
This is where your research will be critical.
If you choose a vehicle just based upon size, fuel mileage and
horsepower, you may not get what you need. Many CUVs are not rated
by their manufacturers for towing trailers over 2,500 pounds. But
there is a growing number that can.
Finding out what a CUV can tow begins with the
information provided from the manufacturer. Don’t trust your
dealer’s salesman to have the answer. The information for towing is
also not often found on the manufacturer’s public website. This
means you will need to see the owner’s manual, or research the
information on towing from reviewers who list the information. But
your best source will always be the owner’s manual for the vehicle
you are looking at. Many times when you are looking at a new vehicle
at the showroom or dealer’s lot, the owner’s manual is not inside
the vehicle. Those are often put in the vehicle at the time of the
sale. So, you may have to ask the salesman to get you a copy of the
owner’s manual to examine.
Towing with a CUV that is properly outfitted
will be much the same as any other tow vehicle. But getting CUV that
is too light, even if it is rated to pull a heavy load, is also a
problem that can occur. I have seen this with some lighter CUV tow
vehicles that have strong engines, but while they have no trouble
with pulling the load on the highway, their tracking is a
frightening, white-knuckle experience where every gust of wind and
passing truck has the vehicle struggling to stay on the road.
When selecting a CUV, keep in mind that the
vehicle’s weight plays a role in the stability of the vehicle when
towing. Don’t select a CUV that has a maximum rated towing capacity
that is close to the weight of your boat and trailer. You will not
see very good performance if you do so.
You should, however, select a CUV that has a
towing capacity well in excess of the total weight of your boat and
trailer, complete with gear and fuel. I also do not recommend towing
a typical boat (17 to 19-feet) with any CUV with a four-cylinder
engine.
The power requirements for towing usually
requires an engine with enough torque to pull the boat up from the
ramp and for towing down the highway without struggling. More torque
is better the less torque. In this case, V6 engines are best for
CUVs considered for towing. You should consider CUVs with horsepower
ratings above 225 and torque rates above 200 as well.
You also should keep in mind that tow ratings
by manufacturers reflect equipping vehicles with special towing
packages that often include a bigger radiator, and coolers for the
transmission as well as a larger alternator. Just adding a trailer
hitch after your purchase does not mean your CUV will be properly
equipped for towing.
Some manufacturers, such as Honda and Acura,
anticipate their vehicles will be used to tow and come complete from
the factory with the necessary equipment for pulling a trailer.
Other manufacturers add the towing package as an add-on item. I
recommend that you choose your vehicle with the factory tow package
whenever possible. Such packages represent the best choice and are
designed to work well with your vehicle. The towing package is also
often less expensive from the dealer than adding the necessary items
afterward, and you get the benefit of the factory warranty.
NEW EXPERIENCES
Towing with a unibody vehicle introduces some
other new experiences. Noise levels with the trailer attached are
often higher. You will hear the hitch moving against the pin in
receiver-type hitches, the road vibrations will also be higher in
the cabin. This occurs because the hitch mounts directly to the body
of the CUV instead of to the frame rails as on regular SUVs and
pickups. There are some solutions to the increase in noise. You can
purchase a hitch pin from an aftermarket supplier who makes
“Quiet-Ride” hitch pins that will reduce the noise for any tow
vehicle. (www.softride.com)
Obviously, towing is not a routine driving
activity. Having the right vehicle for the job is a critical factor
in safety, both for your boat, and for your family. Buying a CUV
that is not up to the towing requirements will put you at risk.
When making a purchasing decision on a CUV that
you plan to use to tow your boat, you should ask the dealer if you
can test the vehicle out with your boat and trailer. Many CUVs do
come with factory-install receiver hitches.
CUVs offer the advantage over most SUVs in
daily use with better fuel mileage, handling and comfort, but they
may not be a solution as a good tow vehicle, this is especially true
for heavier boats. That is why knowing your boat and trailer’s
weight is important before you buy. It may be that your best choice
will remain with a full-size, ladder frame SUV such as a Ford
Expedition, or Chevy Tahoe, or even a Dodge Durango, all of which
have much greater towing ability than CUVs, and have more powerful,
and torquey V8 engines.
To read more GCN AutoMedia Vehicle Reviews visit the
GCN AUTOMEDIA VEHICLE ARCHIVE

 |